Carly Karnatz — a college freshman from East Carolina University — regretted matching with a guy that wouldn't stop messaging her. Her plan of action? Troll him to no end, and she had the perfect storyline in mind.
3. Karnatz Used The Plot Of One Of The Most Popular Animated Films
Karnatz jumps right in by explaining that she lives near a reef and her brother was kidnapped by a bunch of divers while swimming out to a boat and her father tried to rescue him. Sounds familiar, right?
Karnatz tells Matthew her family received a tip that her brother and other prisoners are being held in a tank. The man holding them captive is Philip Sherman, and although this detail should be a dead giveaway, the plot continues to unfold.
Matthew is shocked that Karnatz feels comfortable telling him such a personal story, and he states that he is "a complete stranger." You would think at this point the gig would be up, but it's not until Karnatz reveals one last detail that he realizes he's been duped.
Karnatz tells Matthew her brother is being held captive at 42 Wallaby Way, Sydney, Australia, and everyone who's anyone knows that famous location from Finding Nemo. Matthew, realizing it's a hoax, tells Karnatz she most likely isn't "the one."
11. Karnatz Posted The Entire Conversation To Twitter And It Went Viral AF